I really wanted to like Terminator Salvation so much. After the disappointment of Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines, I was genuinely excited by the early buzz that surrounded this McG-helmed sequel. The trailers looked decent. As did the promo pictures. Sure, I figured that McG would not do as good a job as James Cameron would (how could he?) but I was anticipating a solid piece of sc-fi movie-making to set the T-franchise back on track.
If you’ve been reading the reviews out there, you would be aware that the critics basically hate Terminator Salvation. And there’s good reason for all the bile being thrown its way. But I wanted to take a step back and try to analyse where Terminator Salvation succeeds (and it does in parts) and where it fails.
So, let’s start with its strengths. This is a visually compelling film. McG has pulled out all the stops to make the action sequences as immersive a film experience as possible. The viewing perspective in John (Christian Bale) Connor’s helicopter from the opening sequence is breath-taking. Sure, there are various elements of the Matrix, Transformers, Road Warrior and the first two Terminators referenced throughout the fight scenes, but McG – to his credit – has managed to up the ante, even if ever so slightly. It’s pure movie eye candy from start to finish and from that angle, a pleasure to watch.
Unfortunately for McG, the merits of a film hinges on its storytelling (as well) and on this count, Terminator Salvation fails miserably. How in the world did a script this bad ever get approved for shooting? Worse still, the plot does not even relate properly to the original premise of the franchise as carefully outlined in the first two movies. I could spend hours expounding on the numerous plot holes, poor characterization, logic gaps and plain stupidity permeating this entire movie. But I won’t.
Let’s put it simply, shall we? (Warning… spoilers abound!)
As set up, this movie takes place before John Connor becomes the leader of the resistance and way before Kyle (Anton Yelchin) Reese becomes the man who would go back in time to father John Connor in the past. So why would these two insignificant individuals be on top of Skynet’s kill list? And why would Skynet hatch this improbable plan to lure Connor and Reese to Skynet central in order to kill them? What plan, you say? Well, create a cyborg from the body of death row inmate Marcus (Sam Worthington) Wright to infiltrate the resistance to achieve that aforementioned objective. But why go to all that trouble, when killing Kyle Reese would have meant (as Connor reveals himself) that Connor would never have existed. And believe me, Marcus Wright had ample time and opportunity to kill Kyle Reese, even before Reese himself is captured by the machines (but not killed again, for some mystifying reason).
*Arrggghhhh!!!*
And that is just the tip of the proverbial iceberg. Most of Terminator Salvation does not make any sense whatsover. Like I said before, this movie is sheer eye candy but inside it’s hollow and empty as if the screenwriters and director had no clue (or didn’t give a damn) how to tell the story of the legendary John Connor and Kyle Reese. It’s a pity because there was so much potential.
If you really want to watch Terminator Salvation, a word of caution – don’t bring your brain along.